Subscribe

Donald Trump was sent to Washington for a lot of reasons, not the least of which was major tax reform. He promised to reduce income tax across the board, abolish the death tax, and do a complete overhaul of the system in order to make taxes simpler and fairer.

Business particularly dislikes uncertainty.

One of the largest obstacles to implementing Trump’s tax reform through the budget reconciliation process is the arbitrary budget window put in place back in 1974.  Reconciliation, often referred to as the Byrd Rule in honor of the late Senator Robert Byrd, was established by the Congressional Budget Act of 1974

The premise of Reconciliation is that tax package must pay for themselves in the budget window period covered. The budget window must be passed to last at least 5 years. The period of time the bill covers is known as the “budget window.” Officially, there is no requirement limiting the size of the “budget window.”

At this time, many pundits and politicians claim that the 10-year Budget Window is some sort of a time-honored tradition dating from the founding of our country. Well, it’s not. The Budget Window has bounced around from five to seven years for decades. 2000 was the first year that we ever had a 10-year Budget Window. Before the 10-year period was over, it was changed to a seven-year period. Grover Norquist, president of the Americans for Tax Reform, and David McIntosh, president of the Club for Growth, recently published a compelling opinion piece in the Wall Street Journal.  Their piece, “Tax Cuts that Last-With 51 Votes” makes the case that an increased budget window would greatly improve economic conditions and enable more certain and needed tax reform.  Bold Business endorses their position.

Budget Window is Fun and Games to Congress

Capitol Hill where the Budget Window is set.
Only 51 votes are needed to extend the budget window.

These shenanigans might be all fun and games on Capitol Hill, but this kind of uncertainty has consequences in the real world. Primarily, it costs the country a great loss in economic growth. Businesses need to make long-term decisions, and that requires reliability. The private sector values certainty and long-term stability. If Congress can’t agree on lowering taxes, at the very least they should be able to agree how long a bill will be in effect for. 

A 25-year timeline for tax proposals would make a larger impact on America’s debt ceiling. Given a particular set of circumstances, the business community can adapt and grow. But in chaos, with constantly changing rules, regulations, and taxes, it is almost impossible for a business to chart a course. 25 years also allows changes to stick, rather than be changed immediately by the next presidency. Republicans have recently been very optimistic in their messaging concerning tax reform.  House Speaker Paul Ryan, R-Wis said, “Once in a generation or so, there is an opportunity to do something transformational—something that will have a truly lasting impact long after we are gone,” at the 2017 Manufacturing Summit in Washington, D.C.  Expansion of the budget window would enable this possibility.

Long-term planning in both large and small businesses would be enhanced by increasing the Budget Window to 25 years. The increased predictability and stability would be a positive benefit to businesses all across the country.  Let’s hope the Republicans get out their tools and hammers and build the country an “expaned budget window.”

black and white logo of Bold Wire for Bold Business
The Bold Wire delivers news that matters to you.